IMSLP Forums

Here are two examples of retypeset scores with misprints that remained in this situation for a long time: 1: http://imslpforums.org/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=7221 2: http://imslp.org/index.php?title=Special:WikiForum&thread=5106 (follow this thread http://www.mail-archive.com/tex-music@tug.org/msg...

Nikos wrote:Beethoven Trio Op.38 - Clarinet and Cello parts (the ones uploaded are of poor quality)

There is a better scan of the piano score on: http://imslp.org/wiki/Werke_%28Beethoven,_Ludwig_van%29 Abteilung IV, Band 3, p.103. But sorry, not the "real" clarinet and cello parts

Reinecke-clarinet is there now.

Although we have a set of parts, it is a typeset. This typeset contains many mistakes, at least in the clarinet part, with wrong articulations, wrong notes and at least one missing bar. http://imslp.org/wiki/Peter_and_the_Wolf,_Op.67_%28Prokofiev,_Sergey%29 Isn't there any way to provide this types...

Hamstray wrote:does anyone even update the wishlist when a score is uploaded?

I do when I upload something and am aware of its presence in the wishlist. it would be nice if the imslp server could detect my upload automatically!

@Reinecke: http://imslp.org/wiki/Trio_for_Piano,_C ... cke,_Carl) Hum, a funny situation! The cover page says Violin & Viola and p.2 of the Piano score says these instruments are alternate for 2 wind instruments!

     Maybe it's not important, but I'm curious [...] I see this too often for it to be mere coincidence Maybe it's really not important :-) but I see too often computer-generated scores - from baroque to living composers - with a tiny notation to avoid collisions. On p.2 of this score http://imslp....

Thanks. I thought it was nice to "teach" non-registered users some copyright issue if they don't notice our http://imslp.org/wiki/IMSLP:Copyright_Made_Simple page.

M.J.E. wrote: I care about any score I produce looking as good as possible and looking quite professional, so I couldn't possibly release to the world anything that had such obvious flaws in it

I'll be happy to examine scores you've produced. Are there any on imslp?

although I'd think any self-respecting composer would find out how to correct it before presenting their scores to the world. In France we have the saying: A beautiful calligraphy is the science of donkeys . :-) Would Beethoven have been so productive if he had spent more time writing beautiful man...

M.J.E. wrote:Are there particular programs that tend to do this?

Is there an engraving file available with the scores you're talking about? Then you can know which program was used.

Finale has its own forum for questions like this: http://www.finaleforum.com/
You might recommend the contributors to join it. I imagine other typesetting systems have their own forums.

Done, thanks. A typesetting would have taken about 2-3 weeks.

Worldcat has one "downloadable" result: http://www.worldcat.org/title/collected ... 2529format
But I can't seem to find the "download" button!

I spent $9 to download this from Scribd and it turned out it was only the first movement out of 5!? Are the $9 a permission to download all scribd scores? Sort of a subscription? Or that one only? The pdf I downloaded says at the bottom "Eiendom for alle land" This means "property fo...